AGEZ-POSITIONSPAPIER

CIVIL SOCIETY STATEMENT JOHANNESBURG EARTH SUMMIT MUST AGREE THAT THE WORLD TRADE ORGANIZATION (WTO) RULES WILL RESPECT MULTILATERAL ENVIRONMENTAL AGREEMENTS (MEAs)

Signed by 156 organisations from 49 countries as of 24 May 2002

  WHY IS THERE CONCERN?

UN member governments have an opportunity in Johannesburg to make a clear statement concerning the relationship between Multilateral Environmental Agreements (MEAs) and WTO trade rules, in order to reaffirm the authority and autonomy of MEAs and to ensure that MEAs are not subordinated to or undermined by the WTO. 

At the 4th WTO Ministerial Conference in Qatar, WTO Members decided to launch negotiations on the relationship between MEAs and trade rules because there has been some uncertainty about the relationship between certain MEA provisions and WTO trade rules.  Today, around 20 MEAs have trade-related provisions. 

It is known that due to the rapid development of WTO rules with strong enforcement measures, the implementation of some MEA trade provisions have suffered from a “chilling” effect, with some members arguing that some MEA trade provisions would not be compatible with WTO rules.

Negotiations will come to first results at the next WTO Ministerial Conference in Mexico in mid 2003.

At stake here is the very question of global governance, where the MEAs represent a rare and strategically important space in today's international governance architecture to protect people and the planet. They must be defended and strengthened as a countervailing force to WTO rules.

WHAT SHOULD GOVERNMENTS DO NOW

During the preparatory process for, as well as at, the World Summit on Sustainable Development to be held in Johannesburg, the World Summit on Sustainable Development should:

  • Reaffirm the authority and autonomy of MEAs; and

  • Clarify that the objectives, principles, and provisions of MEAs must not be subordinated to WTO rules. 

Signed first by:

1.        Friends of the Earth International

2.        Greenpeace International

3.        Northern Alliance for Sustainability (ANPED)

4.        Third World Network

5.        Sierra Club

6.        WWF International

Additional signatories:

7.        11.11.11.- Coalition of the Flemish North-South Movement, Belgium

8.        A l'Ecoute de la Nature, France

9.        Action Canada for Population and Development, Canada

10.     ADOME, France

11.     Advocay for Environmental Restoration Zambia (AREZ)

12.     AGEZ (Arbeitsgemeinschaft Entwicklungszusammenarbeit), Austria

13.     Africa-Europe Faith and Justice Network (AEFJN)

14.     Albury-Wodonga Environment Centre, Australia

15.     Allergy, Sensitivity & Environmental Health Association Qld Inc, Australia

16.     Amici della Terra/Friends of the Earth Italy

17.     Anti-Globalisation Network, UK

18.     Asia Pacific Environmental Exchange (APEX)

19.     Attac Austria

20.     Basel Action Network (BAN), US

21.     BC Council for International Cooperation, Canada

22.     Biowatch South Africa

23.     Both ENDS, the Netherlands

24.     Bretton Woods Project, UK

25.     BUND/Friends of the Earth Germany

26.     Campagna per la Riforma della Banca Mondiale/Campaign to Reform the World Bank, Italy

27.     Canadian Council for International Cooperation, Canada

28.     Caroline Lucas, MEP, UK

29.     Center for Development of International Law (CDIL), US

30.     Christenen voor het Socialisme, Belgium

31.     Coalition Clean Baltic - Latvia

32.     CODEFF/Friends of the Earth Chile

33.     Coecoceiba/Friends of the Earth Costa Rica

34.     COHPEDA/AdT-Haiti

35.     COS Groningen, the Netherlands

36.     De Kleine Aarde, Centre for Sustainable Lifestyles (The Small Earth), Boxtel, Holland

37.     Die Verbraucher Initiative, Germany

38.     Dodo - Living Nature For The Future, Finland

39.     Earthlife Africa Johannesburg

40.     Ecodesarollo Gaia, Spain

41.     Ecoropa, France

42.     Environmental Center Biostan, Tashkent, Uzbekistan

43.     Environment Centre of the Northern Territory, Australia

44.     eThekwini ECOPEACE, South Africa

45.     Energy Club, Budapest, Hungary

46.     European Environmental Bureau

47.     Evert Vermeer Foundation, the Netherlands

48.     FAO Community IPM in Indonesia

49.     FERN, Belgium

50.     FIELD (Farmer's Initiatives for Ecological Livelihoods and Democracy), Indonesia

51.     Finnish Association for Nature Conservation (Suomen luonnonsuojeluliitto), Finland

52.     "For Civil Society", Kyrgyzstan

53.     For Poole Agenda 21, UK

54.     Forum for Ssytemdebatt/Forum for System Debate, Sweden

55.     Friends of the Earth Cyprus

56.     Friends of the Earth Middle East

57.     FUTURA, Spain

58.     Germanwatch e.V., Bonn/Berlin, Germany

59.     Global Cooperation Council

60.     Global Network Against Weapons ans Nuclear Power in Space

61.     Green Alliance, UK

62.     Green Belt Movement, Kenya

63.     Green Cross Sweden

64.     Green Youth of Sweden

65.     Grönfront, the Netherlands

66.     HELIO International

67.     Hnuti DUHA/Friends of the Earth Czech Republic

68.     Humanist Institute for Co-operation with Developing countries (HIVOS), the Netherlands

69.     Indonesian IPM (Integrated Pest Management) Farmers' Association, Indonesia

70.     Informationsgruppe Lateinamerika (IGLA), Austria

71.     Initiatives de Développement Stratégique - Stratégic Development Initiative (IDS), France

72.     Institute for Agriculture and Trade Policy (IATP), US

73.     Institute for Economic Relocalisation, France

74.     Irish Seedsavers Association, Ireland

75.     International NGO Task Group on Legal and Institutional Matters (INTGLIM)

76.     Japan Network on Debt & Poverty, member of ICDA, Japan

77.     KEPA - Service Centre for Development Cooperation, Finland

78.     KFEM(Korean Federation for Environmental Movement), Korea

79.     K.U.L.U. - Women and Development, Denmark

80.     KWIA, Flemish Support Group for Indigenous Peoples, Belgium

81.     Le Forum Maghrébin pour l'environnement et le développement ONG, Morocco

82.     Legambiente, Italy

83.     Les Verts, Morocco

84.     LIVANINGO, Mocambique

85.     Maan Ystävät/Friends of the Earth Finland

86.     MAMA TERRA / For Mother Earth-Romania

87.     Milieudefensie/ Friends of the Earth Netherlands

88.     Mineral Policy Institute, Sydney, Australia

89.     Monitoring Network Health and Environment (Meldpunten Netwerk Gezondheid en Milieu), the Netherlands

90.     Move Your World, the Netherlands

91.     National Toxics Network Inc., Australia

92.     Natur og Ungdom (Nature & Youth), Denmark

93.     Naturhomist International, India

94.     Nea Ecologia-Friends of the Earth Greece

95.     Network for Fresh Water Advocacy, Indonesia

96.     NM Ecoglasnost/FoE Bulgaria

97.     Norwegian Forum on Development and Environment, Norway

98.     Open University, UK

99.     Oxfam International

100.  Pacific Institute of Resource Management, New Zealand

101.  Pasumai Thaayagam (Green Mother Land-NGO), Pakistan

102.  Paul Lannoye, MEP, Belgium

103.  Peaceboat, Japan

104.  Pelum Tanzania Network, Tanzania

105.  Plight of The Redwoods Campaign, USA

106.  Polaris Institute, Canada

107.  Public Services International

108.  Programme Sustainable Development, University of Nijmegen, Netherlands

109.  Pro Natura/Friends of the Earth Switzerland

110.  Public Citizen, US

111.  Rechord, UK

112.  Robin Harper MSP, Leader of the Scottish Green Party

113.  Senator Andrew Bartlett, Federal Democrat Senator from Queensland, Australia

114.  Social Action Office(CLRIQ), Australia

115.  Socio-Ecological Union International, Russia

116.  Solagral, France

117.  SOMO, Centre for Research on Multinational Corporations, the Netherlands

118.  South Hams Sustainable Development Group, UK

119.  Southpanafrican Ghana, European Office

120.  Sustainable Population Australia

121.  Stichting Aarde, the Netherlands

122.  Suedwind NÖ, Austria

123.  Swedish Society for the Conservation of Nature, Sweden

124.  Taiwan Environmental Protection Union, Taiwan

125.  Terra Curanda; Globus, Tilburg University, NL-Argentina

126.  Transnational Institute, the Netherlands

127.  The Australian Conservation Foundation (ACF)

128.  The Australian Greens, Australia

129.  The Baltic Centre, Riga

130.  The Danish Ecological Council, Denmark

131.  The Danish Society for Conservation of Nature, Denmark

132.  The Danish 92 Group, Denmark

133.  The European Christian Environmental Network (ECEN)

134.  The future in our hands, Sweden

135.  The Green Library, Lund Sweden

136.  The Green Party of South Africa

137.  The Green Socialist Network, UK

138.  The Tasmanian Conservation Trust, Australia

139.  The Women's Alliance of the Netherlands (Vrouwen Alliantie)

140.  Union for Defence of the Aral Sea and Amudarya (UDASA), Uzbekistan

141.  Ukrainian Environment Asociation Zeleny Svit, Ukraine

142.  VABIKU, Austria

143.  VAK Green Center, Latvia

144.  Vereniging INZET, Associations for North-South Campaigns, the Netherlands

145.  VODO (Flemish Platform on Sustainable Development), Belgium

146.  VOICE (Voice of Irish Concern for the Environment), Ireland

147.  WALHI (Indonesian Forum for Environment)/ Friends of the Earth Indonesia

148.  Warwick & Leamington Green Party, UK

149.  Werkgroep Globalisering DD, the Netherlands

150.  Wildlife and Environment Society of South Africa

151.  Womens International League for Peace and Freedom, France

152.  Women's Network for Sustainability, Canada

153.  World Federalist Movement

154.  WWF Denmark

155.  "Yanus" Environmental-Legal NGO, Armenia

156.  Young Volunteers for Environment of Togo

Countries in total: 49, including Argentinia, Armenia, Australia, Austria, Bulgaria, Canada, Chile, Costa Rica, Czech Republic, Belgium, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Haiti, Hungary, India, Indonesia, Japan, Italy, Kenya, Korea, Kyrgyzstan, Ireland, Latvia, Middle East (groups from Israel, Jordan and Palestine), Morocco, Mocambique, Netherlands, Pakistan, New Zealand, Norway, Romania, Russia, Spain, South Africa, Sweden, Switzerland, Taiwan, Togo, Tanzania, UK, US, Ukraine, Uzbekistan, Zambia

If you still wish to sign on, send the name of your organisation and the country to wssd@foeeurope.org

Regular updated lists will be published at http://www.rio-plus-10.org